A novel approach to study medical decision-making in the clinical setting: The “own-point-of-view” perspective

Abstract

Background

Making diagnostic and therapeutic decisions is a critical activity among physicians. It relies on the ability of physicians to use cognitive processes and specific knowledge in the context of a clinical reasoning. This ability is a core competency in physicians, especially in the field of emergency medicine where the rate of diagnostic errors is high. Studies that explore medical decision-making in an authentic setting are increasing significantly. They are based on the use of qualitative methods which are applied at two separate times: 1) a video recording of the subject's actual activity in an authentic setting and 2) an interview with the subject, supported by the video recording. Traditionally, activity is recorded from an “external perspective”, i.e. a camera is positioned in the room in which the consultation takes place. This approach has many limits, both technical and with respect to the validity of the data collected.

Objectives

The article aims at 1) describing how decision-making is currently being studied, especially from a qualitative standpoint, and the reasons why new methods are needed, and 2) reporting how we used an original, innovative approach to study decision-making in the field of emergency medicine and findings from these studies to guide further the use of this method. The method consists in recording the subject's activity from his own-point-of-view, by fixing a microcamera on his temple or the branch of his glasses. An interview is then held on the basis of this recording, so that the subject being interviewed can relive the situation, in order to facilitate the explanation of his reasoning with respect to his decisions and actions.

Results and conclusions

We describe how this method has been used successfully in investigating medical decision-making in emergency medicine. We provide details on how to use it optimally, taking into account the constraints associated with the practice of emergency medicine, and the benefits in the study of clinical reasoning. The ‘own-point-of-view’ video technique is a promising method to study clinical decision-making in emergency medicine. It is a powerful tool to stimulate recall and help physicians make their reasoning explicit, thanks to a greater psychological immersion.

This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

from Emergency Medicine via xlomafota13 on Inoreader http://ift.tt/2qjFE6j